My Best Sig?

[giatekla]

Which is the best signature? Also, please rate all of them.
http://****************/s/bc07c4e28afb.jpg (http://****************/d/bc07c4e28afb.jpg)
http://****************/s/f5a8c7219025.jpg (http://****************/d/f5a8c7219025.jpg)
http://****************/s/28979abf7bbf.png (http://****************/d/28979abf7bbf.png)

Flanders Man

[Goldpuff]

First one looks too slick and wet.
Second one is OK, but who's the entity in it, and the caption saying giatekla just doesn't blend in.
Third one, Sonic looks like oil fusing around some thing holding some other thing.

6.3/10
6/10
5.9994/10

[pinksixteen]

Um i like ur first one the best (oh and glodpuff its shadow not sonic make ntoe sonic is blue shadow is black and red shadow is not that well known so i dont blame you)

[Kid Nino]

Ok, I like the first one but if you plan on using it might wanna shrink it down a peg. Anyways, I noticed your background is sorta. Boring. I mean I see in the third sig you added some effect but thats just not going to cut it in my opinon you gotta add color's to add to Shadow's bad boy side or to his I can be good side. Its your choice. :)